A Study on the Consent Rules in Personal Information Processing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.62517/jel.202614516
Author(s)
Zhibin Hu
Affiliation(s)
School of Law, China Jiliang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, China
Abstract
The Personal Information Protection Law (PIPL) adopts the "notice–consent" framework as its core architecture and establishes the information subject’s right to self-determination as the value benchmark for personal information processing rules. In light of its institutional function, consent in personal information processing should be positioned as a composite structure that is grounded in quasi-juristic acts and supplemented by the rules governing declarations of will, so as to appropriately accommodate a space for the information subject’s autonomous formation within the statutory protection framework. The determination of "contractual necessity" must be subject to the dual constraints of the purpose limitation principle and the principle of minimum necessity, and should be typologically guided by the distinction between core functions and value-added functions. Judicial practice should strictly examine such issues and provide reasonable grounds to prevent the concept of "contract necessity" from being distorted into a generalized channel, thereby weakening the principle of consent. According to the "independent consent" rule, the regulation of standard terms should be carried out from two dimensions: one is to control the control rights, and the other is to control the effectiveness; by cutting off the improper bundling of "consent" and "service", the independence of consent can be ensured; and the "voluntariness" requirement should be subject to substantive review, negating the validity of "compulsory consent" clauses.
Keywords
Personal Information; Consent Rules; Quasi-Juristic Act; Contractual Necessity; Separate Consent; Standard Terms
References
[1] Yang Xu. The Restrictive Application of the Rule of Necessity for Contract Performance in Personal Information Processing. Law Science, 2023, (06):85–98.
[2] Li Aijun, Sun Yandong. On Personal Information Processing Not Based on Individual Consent and the Systematic Interpretation of the Separate Consent Rule. Journal of Northwestern Polytechnical University (Social Sciences), 2023, (03):112–127.
[3] Green D. Strategic Indeterminacy and Online Privacy Policies: (Un)informed Consent and the General Data Protection Regulation. International Journal for the Semiotics of Law – Revue internationale de Sémiotique juridique, 2024, 38(2):1–29.
[4] Zou Yang. The Legal Effects of Consent Rules in the Personal Information Protection Law. Police Science Research, 2022, (02):5–21.
[5] Lin Hengmin. On the Private Law Nature and Normative Application of Consent by Personal Information Subjects: Also on the Non-Uniformity of Consent under the Civil Code. Comparative Law Research, 2023, (03):142–154.
[6] Sun Zhiyu, Li Yan. On the Dual Structure and Element Determination of "Necessary for Contract" in Personal Information Processing. Social Sciences in Guangdong, 2024, (02):239–250.
[7] Guo Peng, Li Zhanpeng. On the Expansive Application of the Rule of Contractual Necessity in Personal Information Processing. Electronics Intellectual Property, 2024, (06):4–14.
[8] Li Aijun, Sun Yandong. On Personal Information Processing Not Based on Individual Consent and the Systematic Interpretation of the Separate Consent Rule. Journal of Northwestern Polytechnical University (Social Sciences), 2023, (03):112–127.
[9] Han Xuzhi. Notice and Consent in the Processing of Sensitive Personal Information. Local Legislation Research, 2022, 7(03):67–82.
[10]Damian C, Inge G, Peggy V. Pre-formulated Declarations of Data Subject Consent—Citizen-Consumer Empowerment and the Alignment of Data, Consumer and Competition Law Protections. German Law Journal, 2019, 20(05):679–721.
[11]Han Shiyuan. Regulation of Unfair Contract Terms in Chinese Law. Law and Economics, 2017, (04):17–32.
[12]Yang Xianbin. Validity Determination of Standard Terms for Personal Information Processing by Network Platforms. Political Science and Law, 2021, (04):14–25.
[13]Xie Gen. The Normative System for Content Regulation of Standard Terms. Chinese Journal of Law, 2013, 35(02):102–118.