The Integration of Civil Substantive Law and Civil Procedure Law in China
DOI: https://doi.org/10.62517/jel.202614520
Author(s)
Chaolu Zhang
Affiliation(s)
Xinjiang University of Finance and Economics, Urumqi, Xinjiang, China
Abstract
The relationship between substantive law and procedural law has always been a fundamental issue that cannot be avoided in civil litigation law. Due to the disciplinary framework and legislative system, the two have long been regarded as separate departments, but the actual operation of litigation is not like this: from filing a lawsuit to the judgment, substantive elements and procedural requirements are always intertwined, and it is difficult to point out where is purely substantive and where is purely procedural. This article, based mainly on the existing research in the Chinese academic circle, sorts out the alternation of discourses in the three stages of "attachment theory", "independence theory", and "interaction theory", and attributes the basis for integration to three points - litigation as the field where the two laws act together, the two aspects of rights protection (substantive and procedural), and the requirement of uniformity in legal application for systematization. After that, the article examines the disconnection phenomena in legislation, judicial practice and academic research, and then uses four cross-cutting fields - burden of proof allocation, statute of limitations, party qualification and res judicata - to illustrate how integration unfolds at the doctrinal level. The author's basic view is: integration does not eliminate the division of labor between the two laws, but rather reconnects the nodes that should have been connected under the premise of division of labor. The ultimate measure of success or failure is very simple - whether the legal rights can be realized in a real lawsuit.
Keywords
Civil Procedure Law; Civil Substantive Law; Integration; Burden of Proof; Res Judicata
References
[1] Zhang Weiping, The Implementation of the Civil Code and Its Coordination and Connection with Civil Procedure Law, 32(4) Zhongwai Faxue [Peking U. L.J.] 933-950 (2020).
[2] Wang Lei, On the Connection of Application of the Civil Code: The Proposal of a Dynamic View of Legal Sources, 33(1) Zhongwai Faxue [Peking U. L.J.] 87-101 (2021).
[3] Ren Zhong, Coordinated Implementation of the Civil Code and the Civil Procedure Law: Retrospect and Prospect, 37(1) Dangdai Faxue [Contemp. L. Rev.] 44-57 (2023).
[4] Huo Haihong, The Discursive Evolution of the Relationship between Procedure and Substance: Centered on China's "Civil Law", 2010(2) Nanjing Daxue Falü Pinglun [Nanjing U. L. Rev.] 235-249.
[5] Zhang Weiping, The Connection and Integration of the Civil Code and the Civil Procedure Law: Codification of the Civil Code from the Perspective of Civil Procedure Law, 38(1) Faxue Yanjiu [Chinese J.L.] 22-36 (2016).
[6] Chen Gang, On the Substantive Civil Procedure Law, 40(6) Faxue Yanjiu [Chinese J.L.] 128-144 (2018).
[7] Liu Pengfei, An Interactive Examination of Procedural and Substantive Norms in Civil Substantive Law, 43(3) Zhengfa Luntan [Trib. Pol. Sci. & L.] 13-25 (2025).
[8] Ren Zhong, "Detrialization" of Civil Procedure: Taking the Civil Code as a Reference, 2024(3) Fazhi Shehui [Law-Based Society] (2024).
[9] Leo Rosenberg, Die Beweislast [The Burden of Proof] (Zhuang Jinghua trans., China Legal Publishing House 2002).
[10] Li Hao, The Allocation of the Burden of Proof in Civil Judgments: An Analysis of Cases in the Gazette, 2(6) Qinghua Faxue [Tsinghua China L. Rev.] 25-37 (2008).
[11] Huo Haihong, The Chinese Expression of the Burden of Proof for the Interruption of Extinctive Prescription, 33(2) Zhongwai Faxue [Peking U. L.J.] 369-385 (2021).
[12] Wang Yaxin & Chen Xiaotong, The Effect of a Prior Judgment on a Subsequent Action: An Analysis of Articles 93 and 247 of the SPC Interpretation of the Civil Procedure Law, 18(6) Huadong Zhengfa Daxue Xuebao [ECUPL J.] 6-20 (2015).
[13] Wang Lei, The Method of Civil Integration Thinking in the Second Interpretation of the Marriage and Family Book of the Civil Code, 2025(5) Zhongguo Falü Pinglun [China Law Review] 125-140 (2025).