The Testamentary Creation of Rights of Habitation under Chinese Law: Legal Uncertainties and Proposed Reforms
DOI: https://doi.org/10.62517/jel.202614521
Author(s)
Ying He
Affiliation(s)
School of Law, China Jiliang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, China
Abstract
The Civil Code of the People's Republic of China recognizes the right of habitation as a usufructuary right intended to protect residential needs. Article 371 provides that the relevant provisions governing this right apply mutatis mutandis where it is created by will. That provision, however, does not specify how rules designed for contractual creation should be adapted to testamentary dispositions. Two questions remain particularly difficult: Whether the right arises upon the commencement of succession or only upon registration, and whether a testamentary right of habitation must satisfy the written-form requirement applicable to a contract creating such a right. This article examines three competing approaches to registration—constitutive registration, declaratory registration, and registration as a requirement for opposability—and argues in favour of the third as a proposed interpretation of Article 371. On this view, the right should arise when the will becomes operative, while registration should ordinarily be required before the right may be asserted against qualifying good-faith third parties. The article also argues that the formal requirements for wills should not be mechanically equated with those governing contracts. A valid will should not be excluded solely because it is not a conventional paper document, although the statutory requirements for each testamentary form remain mandatory.
Keywords
Right of Habitation; Testamentary Disposition; Application Mutatis Mutandis; Registration and Opposability; Testamentary Formalities
References
[1]Wang Yang. “The Normative Framework for Creating a Right of Habitation by Will.” Contemporary Law Review, 2023, 37(5): 42–53.
[2]Wang Yang. “From Usufruct to the Right of Habitation: The Historical Evolution of Personal Servitudes in Roman Law.” Academic Monthly, 2019, 51(7): 101–112.
[3] Chen Xinyong and Lan Dengjun. “The Origins of the Right of Habitation and Reflections on Its Legislation.” Science of Law, 2003, (3): 68–75.
[4]Wang Liming. “The Application of Mutatis Mutandis Provisions in the Civil Code.” Tribune of Political Science and Law, 2022, 40(1): 44–55.
[5]Guo Hongwei and Jin Jian. “Conflicts and Solutions in Applying the Law to Testamentary Rights of Habitation.” Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences, 2022, (7): 81–92.
[6]Yang Lixin and Li Yiwen. “Amendments to and Application of the Rules on Rights in Rem in the Civil Code.” Journal of Law Application, 2020, (11): 3–40.
[7]Li Yongjun. “The Systematic Position of the Right of Habitation in the Civil Code.” Journal of Comparative Law, 2024, (1): 63–75.
[8]Li Lin. “Distinguishing Testamentary Creation of a Right of Habitation from Succession in the Narrow Sense.” Tsinghua University Law Journal, 2024, 18(2): 161–176.
[9]Jiao Fumin. “Application by Reference of Rules on Testamentary Rights of Habitation.” Political Science and Law, 2024, (10): 100–112.
[10]Fang Shaokun. “On the Right of Habitation under the Civil Code.” Modern Law Science, 2020, 42(4): 83–98.
[11]Qu Ran. “Modes of Creating Rights of Habitation and the Effects of Registration in China.” Law Science Magazine, 2020, 41(12): 90–99.
[12]Xu Jun and Ma Zeyu. “The Effective Time of Testamentary Rights of Habitation and the Effects of Registration.” Real Estate Economics, 2025, 2(5): 37–50.
[13]Xi Zhiguo. “A Doctrinal Analysis of the Right of Habitation.” Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences, 2020, (9): 89–97.
[14]Zheng Qian. “A Systematic Interpretation of the Testamentary Creation of Rights of Habitation.” Contemporary Law Review, 2023, 37(2): 100–110.
[15]Hu Jian and Dong Xiujing. “Application by Reference of the Constitutive Requirements for Testamentary Rights of Habitation.” Journal of Zhejiang Sci-Tech University (Social Sciences), 2026, 56(3): 369–377.
[16]Sun Xianzhong and Zhu Guangxin, eds. Commentary on the Civil Code: Book on Real Rights, Vol. 1. Beijing: China Legal Publishing House, 2020, p. 194.
[17]Feng Jiansheng. “Difficult Issues in Applying the Civil Code Provisions on the Right of Habitation.” Research on Rule of Law, 2023, 147(3): 95–105.