STEMM Institute Press
Science, Technology, Engineering, Management and Medicine
Identification Method and Treatment Measures for Weak Stories in Concrete Frame Structures
DOI: https://doi.org/10.62517/jike.202604412
Author(s)
Xiaokun Li, Hua Jiang*
Affiliation(s)
School of Civil Engineering, Nanning College of Technology, Guilin, Guangxi, China *Corresponding Author
Abstract
A weak story in a concrete frame structure is a level whose lateral stiffness or shear strength is markedly lower than that of adjacent levels, with the result that inelastic deformation concentrates there under strong ground motion. This paper examines how such a story is identified and how it is treated. The formation of weak stories is traced to vertical irregularity in stiffness, irregularity in strength, and the interaction between the two and the story shear demand. Code-based identification criteria are compared, and it is shown that criteria expressed as stiffness ratios and criteria expressed as strength ratios do not always identify the same story, because a story can be flexible yet strong or stiff yet weak. Four identification procedures are then compared, ranging from elastic drift ratios to incremental dynamic analysis, and their resolution and cost are set against each other. Five treatment measures are discussed, including member enlargement, addition of shear walls or braces, installation of damper braces, partial infilling, and base isolation, and the conditions under which each is appropriate are stated. The paper argues that identification and treatment should be linked through the governing limit state, and that the effectiveness of a treatment measure should be verified by the drift profile it produces rather than by the strength it adds.
Keywords
Concrete Frame Structure; Weak Story Identification; Vertical Irregularity; Story Drift Ratio; Seismic Strengthening
References
[1] Tektaş Ş, Tam G, Yön B. Impact of soft-storey irregularity on the seismic safety of reinforced concrete buildings. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2026, 24(10):8759-8789. [2] Demirtaş Y, Avşar Ö, Bozer A, Dindar A A. Investigation of code based criteria for soft-story irregularity. Structures, 2025, 80:109668. [3] Aydıner M F, Sevim B. Investigation of Soft Story Irregularity in RC Structures via Pushover Analysis: From 2D Frames to 3D Buildings. Buildings, 2026, 16(9):1790. [4] Izadpanah M, Shahidzadeh M S, Zibasokhan H. Retrofitting stepped gravity load designed RC buildings with soft-story irregularity by installing hysteretic damper braces. Structures, 2025, 78:109383. [5] Mallikarjuna A, Yadav D, Bhartiya R, Oinam R M, Sahoo D R. Seismic retrofitting of an existing non-ductile open-ground story RC frame by partial infilling with RC shear walls: An experimental study. Engineering Structures, 2025, 335:120397. [6] Aditya L, Tamizharasi G. Comparative assessment and recommendations for code-based identification of vertical stiffness irregularities in reinforced concrete frame buildings. Structural Concrete, 2025, 26(6):8158-8177. [7] Luo R F, Lata A, Dong X Y, Wang B, Luo Z W, Liang Y D, Guo X. Seismic response of soft-story reinforced concrete frames: Challenging traditional collapse mechanisms. Structures, 2025, 76:108894. [8] Akin E, Kanas E. Collapse capacity assessment of non-ductile open ground story reinforced concrete frame. Turkish Journal of Engineering, 2023, 7(2):157-165. [9] Hsiao F P, Lin C C, Weng P W, Haryanto Y, Nugroho L, Huang C H. Alternative strengthening strategies to improve the seismic resilience of RC frame structures. Journal of Building Engineering, 2026, 119:115078. [10] Rahimi A, Maheri M R. The effects of steel X-brace retrofitting of RC frames on the seismic performance of frames and their elements. Engineering Structures, 2020, 206:110149. [11] Zhang Y K. Seismic Performance Analysis of RC Frame Structure Beam-Column Joints Based on Strong Column and Weak Beam Method. Buildings, 2024, 14(10):3267. [12] El-ghareeb J E M, Abd-EL-Mottaleb H E A, Elshamy E A, Emara M. Seismically resistant progressive collapse behavior of infilled frame structures under seismic loads and column loss: A numerical investigation. Structures, 2024, 66:106913. [13] Zhang Y T, He Z. Acceptable values of collapse margin ratio with different confidence levels. Structural Safety, 2020, 84:101938. [14] Paulay T, Priestley M J N. Seismic Design of Reinforced Concrete and Masonry Buildings. Wiley, 1992.
Copyright @ 2020-2035 STEMM Institute Press All Rights Reserved